No. 132 – Trying to time the markets with your investments is not optimal

by | Nov 20, 2024 | Estate Planning, Financial Planning, Investment, Offshore

Question

I have a fixed deposit that has just matured and I want to reinvest it.  I don’t know where I should invest the money as I am very worried about what is going to happen in the next elections. What would you recommend?

Answer

It is difficult to make a call on just one investment. You need an investment plan that is robust and can handle different market conditions.  When I draw up an investment plan, I look at the following:

 

Timeframes

What are your needs over the short, medium and long term. If you need to access a lot of your funds over the short-term then it is important that you do not expose these assets to too much risk. However, if you will only be needing to access these funds after 10 years, we can expose them assets which may go down in value to get a better return.

 

Country exposure

An investment plan needs to take the location of your assets into account. The common wisdom is that you should have between 25% and 40% of your assets physically located offshore. This could reduce the risk of your personal wealth being decimated by any political instability in the country.

 

Please remember to structure these offshore assets carefully to ensure that your heirs can inherit easily in years to come.

 

Risk tolerance

We all have different tolerances when it comes to investment risk. Some of us are comfortable seeing our investments going down over a period if we believe that the asset is going to grow significantly in the future.  Others will have sleepless nights if an investment falls.

 

Each investment carries an element of risk.  A short-term investment like a bank deposit carries very little risk that you will lose your money over the shorter term.  It does, however, carry a risk that you may not be able to meet your needs in the future if the interest rate does not beat inflation.

 

Your investment plan should take your risk tolerance into account.   

 

With a robust plan in place, you can start looking at the implications of events like the sustained load shedding and the coming elections.

 

Many financial companies use something called the tactical asset allocation which takes political and economic events into account when it comes to allocating assets to the different asset categories.  They would recommend for example that you be overweight or underweight in a particular asset category (like local bonds or developing market offshore equity) when looking at the next six months to a year. This can help guide you when rebalancing your portfolio.

 

I would caution you not to try and time the market. What is true is that time in the market his way more important than trying to time the market. I have shown this before but if you were outside of the market for the best 10 days over a 23 year period, your returns would have been 45% lower.  We do not know when the market is going to move dramatically.  Many asset managers are saying that the South African market is undervalued, and a lot of the political uncertainty has been priced into it. If the elections result in a South Africa that is better than expected, the markets could grow.

 

There are a couple of products that your financial advisor could consider. These would include the following:

 

  • Offshore investment

It is easy to move money offshore these days and an offshore investment will immunize you from any fallout from the South African elections. But remember that the offshore market has its own challenges.

 

  • Protected equity

These are investments that typically tie your money up for up for 3 to 5 years.  Your capital would be guaranteed, and you would participate in the upside movement in a particular index.  These products are typically sold in tranches and are usually only available over a six week period.  There are some rather attractive ones on the market at the moment.

 

  • Guaranteed or hedged funds

Here you often have to invest your money for five years. You can get different levels of guarantee for your capital.  The higher the level of guarantee, the more expensive it is to invest in this type of product.

 

  • Balanced Fund

If you have a diversified portfolio and are unlikely to need the funds over the short term, an investment in a balanced fund could be the solution.

 

So, to answer your question, I would recommend that you go back to your initial investment plan and check that it is robust enough to handle differing market conditions.  (If you don’t have one, I would recommend that you get an investment plan drawn up).  You should get your advisor to give you their current tactical asset allocations for the next year and recommend the best place to invest your money.

KENNY MEIRING IS AN INDEPENDENT FINANCIAL ADVISER

Contact him via phone, email or via contact phone on the financialwellnesscoach.co.za website

Read more of our articles on the Daily Maverick website or newspaper weekly!

Oct 20 2025

No. 228 – Plan for the everyday while estate is wound up

Question We are married in community of property and are worried that if one of us dies, everything will be frozen for months or maybe years while the estate is wound...
Oct 20 2025

No. 227 – Ensuring property transfers are fair for all heirs

Question I am 80 years old and have a daughter who lives in my rental property.  She will inherit it when I pass away. She would like  to take over the ownership now. ...
Oct 07 2025

No. 226 – Money priorities every graduate should know

Question I will be finishing university next month and know nothing about financial planning. What should I prioritise?Answer Start with the only asset you already own...
Sep 30 2025

No. 225 – Restructure your assets sensibly to preserve the money for heirs

Question I’m a widow with a terminal diagnosis. I want my two children, both in their 50s, to inherit with minimum cost and delay. I have R5 million in bank accounts,...
Sep 25 2025

No. 224 – Untangle financial choices before tying the knot

Question My partner and I are getting married in December and need to decide whether we are doing it in community of property or with an ante-nuptial contract. Then...
Sep 16 2025

No. 223 – Time plus compound interest equals big returns

Question I’m a 74-year-old ‘financially illiterate’ gran learning so much from your column. I have a newborn grandson and would like to start some sort of ‘fund’ for...
Sep 08 2025

No. 222 – Structures and strategies to help create lasting family wealth

Question I have built up a substantial set of assets and have no debt. How do I structure my finances to create long-term wealth for my children and...
Aug 31 2025

No. 221 – Buy-and-sell structures are crucial for businesses

Question I run a business with two partners. Things are fine now, but what if one of us dies? A friend passed away last year, and it ended up in a messy legal fight...
Aug 28 2025

No. 220 – How to strike the right balance between caution and growth

Question With inflation now around 3%, the Reserve Bank cut rates by 0.25%. That’s great for borrowers, but I’m a 68-year-old pensioner living off the interest from a...
Aug 19 2025

No. 219 – Using extra money smartly can maximise your retirement funds

Question My spouse has no pension or retirement fund. He has just sold a property and now has a few million in the bank. Can we put that into my pension or retirement...

Download the Life File